Purpose of Formative Feedback
Formative feedback provides specific, actionable guidance to leaders to help them understand their current progress, identify gaps, and improve their knowledge, skills, and abilities. It is designed to guide improvement and growth, in alignment with the college's mission, vision, values, and strategic goals. The aim of formative feedback, per VCCS Policy 3.6.1 is to assist the faculty member in identifying strengths and developing strategies for self-improvement. Additional formative feedback, especially from the faculty member's supervisor, is expected to be provided by formal and informal means on an ongoing basis.
Procedures
The policy and procedure for Formative Feedback has been established through the College's Policy 423: Formative Feedback
Scope:
The procedures apply to full-time administrative and professional faculty members.
Frequency of Formative Feedback:
The survey will be administered to faculty every other year, based on their date of hire or effective date of the position with the college. For example, those hired in an even year, like 2022, will be evaluated in even years such as 2028. Those hired in an odd year, like 2007, will be evaluated in odd years such as 2027. Please observe the following notations/exceptions:
- Resignations or retirements: Those who have announced their resignation/retirement are exempt from the process if the effective date is within six months of the survey being administered in mid-January. For 2027, this is an effective retirement or resignation date of July 15, 2027.
- New hires: Those who were recently hired by the college are exempt from the process until they have six months of service. For 2027, this is a hire date of July 15, 2026.
- New hires will receive a formative feedback survey each January for three consecutive years, before moving to the biennial schedule.
- Leadership retains the discretion to initiate a formative feedback survey at any time outside the routine frequency.
Human Resources will notify administrative and professional faculty who will have a formative feedback survey administered for them in January.
Raters:
It is the administrative or professional faculty member's responsibility to review the raters with their supervisor and submit the Approved Raters Form to Human Resources by the due date. Supervisors must review and approve the raters. For 2027, this due date will be January 8, 2027.
Raters include:
- Direct reports (will be invited)
- Peer raters
- Colleague raters
- Skip-down level raters
Number of raters invited:
| # of Direct Reports |
# of Additional Raters Invited |
| 0 |
7-8 |
| 1-5 |
7-11 |
| 5-10 |
4-8 |
| 10+ |
6-8 |
Distribution of Formative Feedback Survey and Results:
Human Resources is responsible for distributing the formative feedback survey. Survey collection will be open from January 15 to February 15. Confidentiality must be preserved during this process. Each rater's scores will be compiled, and an average score will be calculated. The final consolidated data and all comments will be provided to the administrative or professional faculty member's director supervisor, who will provide a copy to the faculty member. The direct supervisor is responsible for utilizing the data for professional development as an addendum to the evaluation documents that are due July 1 of each year per VCCS Policy 3.6.1. A sample of the survey is attached at the right side of the screen.